Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valve
Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
Pilot operated pressure relief valves (PORVs), also known as pilot-operated safety valves (POSVs), are essential safety devices used in various industries to protect equipment and systems from overpressure conditions. Unlike conventional spring-loaded pressure relief valves, PORVs utilize a pilot valve to control the opening and closing of the main valve. This design offers several advantages, making them suitable for specific applications where conventional valves may not be the ideal choice. This article explores the key aspects of PORVs, including their working principles, types, advantages, disadvantages, applications, and maintenance. It also delves into the research and development efforts shaping the future of these critical safety components.
What is a Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valve?
A pilot-operated pressure relief valve (PORV) is a type of pressure relief valve that uses a small, self-actuated auxiliary valve, known as the pilot valve, to control the opening and closing of the main valve1. This design allows the PORV to handle higher pressures and flow rates compared to conventional spring-loaded valves5.
In a PORV, the main valve piston is balanced by the system pressure, which is routed to the dome above the piston through a pilot tube5. The pilot valve monitors the system pressure and, when the pressure exceeds the set point, it opens and releases the pressure from the dome. This causes the main valve to open and relieve the excess pressure from the system4.
One of the key differences between PORVs and conventional spring-loaded pressure relief valves (PRVs) lies in the closing force mechanism. In conventional PRVs, a spring provides the closing force, while in PORVs, the process pressure itself is used to keep the valve closed6. This difference in design contributes to the unique advantages of PORVs, such as tighter sealing and reduced chatter.
To understand the function of a PORV, it’s important to consider the three types of pressure that these valves help maintain: 2
- Cracking Pressure: The pressure at which the valve begins to open and the first drop of fluid is released.
- Full Flow Pressure: The pressure required for the valve to fully open and allow the maximum flow rate.
- Reseat Pressure: The pressure at which the valve closes completely after being open. This is typically lower than the cracking pressure.
Types of Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
PORVs can be categorized into two main types based on their opening and closing behavior:
- Pop Action Valves: These valves open abruptly and completely when the set pressure is reached. They are suitable for applications requiring rapid response and maximum flow4.
- Modulating Valves: These valves open gradually and proportionally to the overpressure. They offer better control over the pressure relief process and minimize the loss of the process medium4.
In addition to these two types, PORVs can be further classified as flowing or non-flowing. Flowing pilot-operated safety relief valves (POSRVs) have a pilot valve that remains open during normal operation, allowing a small amount of fluid to flow through. Non-flowing POSRVs, on the other hand, have a pilot valve that remains closed during normal operation, and only opens when the system pressure exceeds the set point7. The choice between pop action and modulating valves, as well as flowing and non-flowing types, depends on the specific application requirements.
Advantages of Using a Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valve
PORVs offer several advantages over conventional spring-loaded pressure relief valves:
- Higher Operating Pressure: PORVs can handle higher operating pressures compared to spring-loaded valves due to the balanced piston design4.
- Tighter Sealing: PORVs provide better seat tightness, minimizing leakage at pressures below the set point5. This tight sealing capability also contributes to reduced emissions, particularly in applications involving volatile organic compounds (VOCs)10.
- Reduced Chatter: The pilot-operated design reduces the risk of valve chatter, which can damage the valve and cause instability11.
- Remote Control: The pilot valve can be mounted remotely, allowing for easier access and control5.
- Improved Efficiency: PORVs can operate closer to the set pressure, reducing the blowdown and minimizing product loss9.
- Flexibility: PORVs offer more options for control and customization, including adjustable blowdown and various accessories12.
Applications of Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
PORVs are used in various industries for overpressure protection in a wide range of applications: 13
- Oil and Gas: Upstream and downstream oil and gas processing, including offshore platforms and pipelines1.
- Chemical Processing: Protecting reactors, vessels, and pipelines from overpressure7.
- Power Generation: Protecting boilers, steam lines, and other equipment in power plants7. The ASME code was recently revised to allow the use of PORVs in Section I boiler applications due to their proven effectiveness and reliability, particularly in economizer applications where conventional spring-loaded valves were prone to chatter11. In nuclear power plants, PORVs are used in pressurizer safety valve applications, with designs categorized as “cold state structure” and “hot state structure” based on the pilot valve configuration16.
- Pulp and Paper: Pressure relief in digesters, evaporators, and other equipment7.
- Food and Beverage: Protecting tanks and processing equipment in food and beverage production10.
- Other Industries: Pharmaceutical, water treatment, and general industrial applications14. A typical tank installation often includes a pilot-operated pressure/vacuum relief valve, a gas blanketing regulator, and an emergency pressure relief valve3.
Manufacturers of Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
Several manufacturers produce PORVs, each offering a range of products with different features and specifications. The following table summarizes some of the leading manufacturers and their offerings:
| Manufacturer | Product Series | Applications | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emerson | Anderson Greenwood Series 200/400/500/700/800, Crosby J-Series, Anderson Greenwood Series 9300H | High-pressure, low-pressure, steam service | Maximized operating pressures, minimized emissions, reliable performance |
| Trillium Flow Technologies | Sarasin-RSBD® Series (71, 74LP, 74VP, 76, 78, 78LP, 86), SEBIM® Series (CSSV 3000, CTSV 3000, DSM 3000, GVG 3000, PRG 2000, PRG 3000), Stareco (76E Series) | Oil and gas, nuclear power, general industry | Application-specific designs, high performance, tight shut-off |
| Groth Corporation | Model 16F | Low-pressure applications | Reliable low-pressure protection, prevents fugitive emissions, conserves stored product |
| LESER | Pop Action, Modulating Action | Various industrial applications | Higher operating pressure, full seat tightness, low vibration sensitivity |
| Curtiss-Wright | Farris 1890, 2400, 2600, 2600L, 2700, 3800, 4200, 6400, 1896, 4700 Series | Process and steam applications | Modulating control, reduced emissions, smaller design |
| Consolidated | 3900/3900 TM Series, 2900/2900 TM Series, 2900-40, 13900 Series | Gas, liquid, and steam applications | Zero leakage at high operating pressure, stable overpressure cycle, flexible design |
| Pietro Fiorentini | – | High and medium pressure gas applications | Immediate action in case of line pressure variations |
When selecting a PORV, it is essential to consider the specific application requirements, such as pressure, temperature, flow rate, and fluid compatibility, and choose a valve that meets those needs. While some PORVs may have manual controls for testing or specific situations, they are primarily designed to operate automatically in response to system pressure9.
Comparison of Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves and Direct-Acting Relief Valves
While both pilot-operated and direct-acting relief valves serve the purpose of overpressure protection, they differ in their design and operating characteristics. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the most suitable valve for a given application.
Direct-acting relief valves are simpler in design, with a spring directly acting on the valve poppet to keep it closed8. They are typically faster in response to pressure changes, making them suitable for applications requiring rapid pressure relief. However, they have a higher pressure override, meaning the pressure may rise significantly above the set point before the valve fully opens2.
Pilot-operated relief valves, on the other hand, utilize a pilot valve to control the main valve, offering more precise pressure control and lower pressure override2. They can handle higher flow rates and are less prone to chatter. However, they are generally slower to respond to pressure spikes compared to direct-acting valves8.
The following table summarizes the key differences between pilot-operated and direct-acting relief valves:
| Feature | Pilot-Operated Relief Valve | Direct-Acting Relief Valve |
|---|---|---|
| Design Complexity | More complex | Simpler |
| Response Time | Slower | Faster |
| Pressure Override | Lower | Higher |
| Flow Capacity | Higher | Lower |
| Chatter | Less prone | More prone |
| Cost | Generally more expensive | Generally less expensive |
| Applications | High-pressure, high-flow applications, applications requiring precise pressure control | Applications requiring rapid response, moderate flow rates, cost-sensitive applications |
Maintenance and Troubleshooting of Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
Proper maintenance and troubleshooting are crucial to ensure the reliable operation of PORVs. A failing pressure relief valve is often a symptom of a larger problem in the system, and it’s important to investigate the root cause rather than simply replacing the valve21. Some common maintenance tasks include:
- Regular Inspection: Inspect the valve for any signs of damage, corrosion, or leakage. This includes checking the valve body, pilot valve, pilot lines, and any associated accessories. Look for signs of wear, cracks, or any other abnormalities that may affect the valve’s performance.
- Cleaning: Clean the valve and pilot valve to remove any dirt or debris that may affect its performance. This may involve disassembling the valve and cleaning the internal components.
- Testing: Perform regular testing to verify the valve’s set pressure and leakage rate22. This can be done using a test manifold and following the manufacturer’s recommended procedures.
- Calibration: Recalibrate the valve if necessary to ensure it operates at the correct set pressure21. Calibration may involve adjusting the pilot valve or other components to achieve the desired set pressure.
Troubleshooting common PORV problems may involve:
- Failure to Open: Check for a broken spring in the pilot valve, a blocked damping hole, or a stuck main valve core23.
- Unstable Limit Pressure: Adjust the pressure setting, check the pilot valve core spring for bending or softening, or replace contaminated oil23.
- Leakage: Tighten or replace bonnet bolts, tighten packing gland nuts, or replace the valve if necessary22. Leakage can be caused by various factors, including damage to the valve seat, debris in the valve, or incorrect valve sizing.
It is important to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for maintenance and troubleshooting to ensure the safe and efficient operation of the PORV. Design considerations for relief valves include ensuring low-pressure drop before the valve to avoid instability, considering differences between gas and liquid duties, and accounting for the impact of back pressure on opening/closing pressures, stability, and capacity. Regular proof checks are also required to verify the lifting pressure, especially in corrosive environments24.
Research and Development in Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
Ongoing research and development efforts focus on improving the performance, reliability, and safety of pilot-operated pressure relief valves. Some areas of research include:
- Pilot Pressure Feedback: Investigating the impact of pilot pressure feedback on valve performance and stability25.
- Design of Pilot-Operated Relief Valves: Addressing challenges related to dynamic transients and potential valve opening even when the pilot stage is closed25.
- Overflow Energy Loss: Minimizing energy losses in pilot-operated proportional relief valves to improve efficiency25.
These research efforts contribute to the advancement of PORV technology and its application in various industries.
Future Trends in Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves
The future of pilot-operated pressure relief valves is likely to be shaped by several emerging trends:
- Smart Valves: Integrating sensors and intelligent control systems into PORVs to enable real-time monitoring, diagnostics, and predictive maintenance26.
- Advanced Materials: Utilizing new materials and coatings to improve valve performance in high-pressure, high-temperature, and corrosive environments.
- Miniaturization: Developing smaller and more compact PORVs for use in space-constrained applications.
These trends will further enhance the capabilities and applications of PORVs in various industries.
Conclusion
Pilot-operated pressure relief valves are critical safety devices that offer significant advantages over conventional spring-loaded valves. Their ability to handle higher pressures, provide tighter sealing, reduce chatter, and offer greater flexibility makes them essential components in various industrial applications. While they may be more complex and expensive than spring-loaded valves, their benefits often outweigh the drawbacks, especially in demanding applications.
The ongoing research and development efforts, coupled with emerging trends like smart valves and advanced materials, are poised to further enhance the performance, reliability, and safety of PORVs. As industries continue to push the boundaries of pressure and temperature limits, PORVs will play an increasingly vital role in ensuring the safe and efficient operation of critical systems. Proper maintenance and troubleshooting, guided by a thorough understanding of the valve’s operating principles and potential failure modes, are essential to maximize the lifespan and reliability of these crucial safety components.
Works cited
1. How Does A Pilot-Operated Valve Work? – Trillium Flow Technologies, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.trilliumflow.com/tf-news/how-does-a-pilot-operated-valve-work/
2. A Guide To Direct Acting Vs. Pilot Operated Relief Valves – Hydraulic Specialty, accessed February 6, 2025, https://hydraulicspecialty.com/direct-acting-vs-pilot-operated-relief-valves/
3. Pilot Operated Relief Valves, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.crossco.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/LIT1307_Pilot_Operated_Relief_Valves_2020_Web.pdf
4. Pilot-operated Pressure Relief Valves – LESER, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.leser.com/en-us/products/pilot-operated-pressure-relief-valves/
5. Pilot-operated relief valve – Wikipedia, accessed February 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot-operated_relief_valve
6. Farris: How to choose between conventional and pilot operated pressure relief valves, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.awc-inc.com/farris-how-to-choose-between-conventional-and-pilot-operated-pressure-relief-valves/
7. Fundamental Operation of Pilot-Operated Safety Relief Valves | Baker Hughes DAM, accessed February 6, 2025, https://dam.bakerhughes.com/m/2c919e250c65d509/original/Fundamental-Operation-of-Pilot-Operated-Safety-Relief-Valves.pdf
8. Direct Acting Relief Valve vs Pilot Operated: Complete Guide, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.hydraflu.com/direct-acting-relief-valve-vs-pilot-operated/
9. Pressure Relief Valves | cw-valvegroup, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.cw-valvegroup.com/en-gb/products/pressure-relief-valves
10. Pilot Valves – An Exploration of Industrial Technology, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.pioneerindustrial.com/pilot-valves-an-exploration-of-industrial-technology/
11. New Uses for Pilot-operated Safety Relief Valves – Power Engineering, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.power-eng.com/operations-maintenance/new-uses-for-pilot-operated-safety-relief-valves/
12. Pilot-Operated Safety Relief Valves, accessed February 6, 2025, https://valves.bakerhughes.com/consolidatedpilot-operated-safety-relief-valves
13. en.wikipedia.org, accessed February 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot-operated_relief_valve#:~:text=Like%20other%20pressure%20relief%20valves,the%20pressure%20to%20dangerous%20levels).
14. The Ultimate Guide to Pilot Operated Valves for Efficient Control Systems | THINKTANK, accessed February 6, 2025, https://cncontrolvalve.com/ultimate-guide-to-pilot-operated-valves/
15. Solving Overpressure Protection Challenges With Conventional & Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves Kevin Olsen AWC, Inc., accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.awc-inc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Pilot-Operated-PRV-Advantages.pdf
16. Analysis and research on technical characteristics of pilot-operated pressurizer safety valves, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.spiedigitallibrary.org/conference-proceedings-of-spie/13159/1315923/Analysis-and-research-on-technical-characteristics-of-pilot-operated-pressurizer/10.1117/12.3024703.full
17. Pressure Relief Valves | Emerson US, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.emerson.com/en-us/automation/valves/pressure-relief-valves
18. Pilot Operated Pressure Relief Valves – Trillium Flow Technologies, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.trilliumflow.com/products/valves/pilot-operated-pressure-relief-valves/
19. Groth Corporation Announces New Pilot Operated Relief Valve, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.grothcorp.com/groth-corporation-announces-new-pilot-operated-relief-valve/
20. Pilot operated relief valves – Pietro Fiorentini, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.fiorentini.com/en/category/solutions/products/gas-products/valves/pilot-operated-relief-valves/
21. Setting and Troubleshooting Relief Valves in Hydraulic Systems, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.hydparts.com/blog/50/setting-and-troubleshooting-relief-valves-in-hydraulic-systems
22. Pressure Relief Valve Failure and Troubleshooting – Tameson.com, accessed February 6, 2025, https://tameson.com/pages/pressure-relief-valve-failure-troubleshooting
23. Typical Failures of Pilot Relief Valve – Adamant Valves, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.adamantvalves.com/typical-failures-of-pilot-relief-valve.html
24. Safety Relief Valve: A Pressure Relieving Device – Piping Engineering, accessed February 6, 2025, http://www.piping-engineering.com/safety-relief-valve-a-pressure-relieving-device.html
25. A Review of Pilot-operated Hydraulic Valves – Development, Challenges, and a Comparative Study – ResearchGate, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375469917_A_Review_of_Pilot-operated_Hydraulic_Valves_-_Development_Challenges_and_a_Comparative_Study
26. A Review of Safety Valves: Standards, Design, and Technological Advances in Industry, accessed February 6, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9717/13/1/105